I
think I’ve figured out Scott Snyder, what makes him tick, and perhaps why some
of his comics turn to poop. Maybe I’ve also figured out what reduces him to a
quivering mess in his bed at night. Before I get into it I’d like to preface
all of this by saying I consider Scott to be one of the pre eminent comic book
writers of our time. He’s imaginative, versatile and wonderful at crafting
engaging plots. I’ve said this before but his ‘Court of Owls’ run on the main Batman title is, in my opinion, the
greatest Batman story ever told. His run on Batman was also one of the greatest
runs on that comic, ever. But, if you’ll remember, it kind of ended oddly, didn’t it?
So
let’s return back to the end of Snyder’s Batman run, it was the whole Mr. Bloom
storyline, right? Now, I don’t remember the specifics of the story line but I
do remember the final issues feeling rushed and out of sorts. The absolute last
Synder issue was befuddling as somehow Commissioner Gordon became the hero, not
Batman and, it just felt off. Now, this was a while ago but I distinctly remember
putting that issue down with a bad taste in my mouth. Really? That’s how one of
the greatest Bat writers ever goes out? Now, that’s neither here nor there but
let’s take a look at the Bloom dude:
Pointy Talons, impaling people, tall, skinny. Okay,
now catalog that image in your head. So, Snyder’s Batman run ends in 2016 but back
in 2014 he put out a limited series called ‘Wytches’
which was an amazing horror comic. It may be one of my favorite horror comics
of all time and I’m not a big fan of the horror genre. Anyway, it concealed the
look of the actual Wytches of the story until the very end which really amped
up the tension and intrigue; you had to know who these Wytches were. Well, once
you saw them, I mean, look, it was still a great story but, I dunno, a little
wacky, not gonna lie. It was kind of hard to find an image of them and there’s
no way I’m searching through dozens of comic book boxes for the issues but they
kind of looked like this
They
were lanky with long arms, disproportionately large and small eye sockets,
absurdly long talon-like fingers. Also, the main character ended up somehow
entering one of the trees through a tree knot which led to this extensive
subterranean lair that seemed to stretch for miles. At this point we got Bloom
and Wytches. Okay, next up we have the Batman Who Laughs that became
immensely popular during that whole ‘Metal’ run, which I thought was mediocre
at best. Yeah, thinking back on that Metal stuff it was pretty bad. Like, I
couldn’t even tell you what happened and there were a shit ton of issues;
expensive ones I might add. Yet the crown jewel of that entire storyline was
the creation of a dark alternate reality version of Batman called the ‘Batman
who Laughs’. Clearly a Joker-esque character mold. Let’s take a look at the BWL:
Starting
to see a pattern here? Tall, lanky, pointy dude things. Fast forward to his
Dark Horse/Comixology Original reprints and he’s right back with the Pointies.
His ‘We Have Demons’ was a complete
and utter mess, gory, gross and generally silly BUT he did have copious amounts
of spiky pointy things. Here's the cover of the first issue which could have been called 'We Have Spiky Nightmares'.
Next was ‘Night
of the Ghoul’, which I reviewed here 'Night of the Ghoul', and sure enough look at what’s
sloughing after the kid in another subterranean expanse that seems to go on forever:
Next
up, his ‘Barnstormers’ story, one of
my absolute favorites of 2023. Now, one would think, okay it’s a Romance in the
skies type story so we’re not going to see any Snyder nightmare beings,
actually, you’d be wrong about that. The main character dude is tormented
by dreams of a tall lanky Robot with big shining eyes. Do I have to keep going???
Finally
we’re at ‘Canary’. Now, I was really enjoying
this one, a major page turner. Snyder, per usual, set up the world and main
characters perfectly and really built the suspense through the first two
issues. I had to know ‘What’s up with this mine? What’s in it? Why are people
going bonkers because of it?’ Now through the first two issues there were some
gruesome horrific elements but nothing too off the walls. I think Snyder
crafted a fine balance between a grounded Mystery in a remote Western town with
a cast of characters that weren’t clichéd or one dimensional at all. I
genuinely was looking forward to the third issue and the big reveal.
Well, all this final issue revealed is that Scott Snyder needs therapy. This
issue totally went off the rails, careening into the depths of Wackadoodleville.
My goodness. What a shit show. What a disappointing mess. So our heroes find
their way into the mine and gee, guess what, it goes down thousands and
thousands of feet into a deep subterranean world that goes on forever; more
subterranean empire stuff. The female lead’s Dad lords over the subterranean ‘Mine
World’ and this is what he looks like.
Not
only that, once our lead Vigilante dude comes upon the Spiky Emperor of shiny pointy
things he finds that his two accomplices, the babe and the geologist dude, have
been impaled through their midsections by Daddy Talonbucks.
Major gripe alert,
the chick and the dude who were run through by these elongated demon spikes
obviously escape. Now, I can somehow believe their adrenaline fuels them to run
at top speed from the Pointy Army of Death despite the fact that they have a
major hole in their body that’s not been cauterized or stopped in any way. Yet
once they get to the surface – what, nothing? Like, oh, yeah we were impaled
but, yeah, that was a few pages ago. They don’t collapse, they don’t reach for
the wound, it’s like it never happened. C’mon Scottie, deal with the pointy
trauma.
Here’s
what I think happened. Snyder starts with the pointy teeth theme with American
Vampire in 2010. He then goes on to have a massive success with his Batman run
which started around 2012 or so. With success comes great responsibility and
pressure. At some point he probably went to therapy, or maybe even better,
signed up for an Ayuhuasca ceremony to connect with the Great Spirit of comic
book writing: Jack Kirby. One of these sessions went awry and it brought up a
buried nightmare of his, that of a tall bug eyed lanky point fingered monster
thingy that lived under his bed or in his closet as a child. I had one like
this when I was kid, I was terrified of the Nosferatu Vampire, notice the
similarities with the Synder Monster Canon?
Maybe
Scott also saw Nosferatu as a kid and it drove him batty, no pun intended. So
while enjoying Bat success he decides to exorcise his demons (perhaps his We Have
Demons title is him admitting that he still has them) and writes Wytches; the
first instance of the lanky bug eyed pointy monster thingy. Unfortunately it
opens up a Pandora’s Box of repressed fear and psychosis for Snyder which
spurs him on to write the Mr Bloom story line. As the story progresses Snyder regresses
and becomes more and more volatile to the point where he’s a blubbering mess at
DC Editorial meetings. He’s wailing ‘Pointy
Pointy Pointy! BIG eyes! Big! Ooooh very big! Tall Big Pointy Pointy Pointy!’
At this point DC knows they have to can him or give him a break which is why
Mr. Bloom ends with a thud.
Weeks
later Snyder shows up to DC offices again. He’s been told to stay away for a
couple of months to get his act together and see a shrink. He ignores this
advice and completely loses his shit instead. He shows up to DC dressed up as
the Batman who Laughs. Maybe he looked like this:
Of
course, if you’re walking around New York City like this nobody is going to
blink an eye. They’d just assume you’re in a Death Metal Band or work for the
Mayor. Now, DC could either wrap him up in a straight jacket or squeeze the
insanity out of him and release a whole new series of Snyder Stuff for $5-6
bucks a pop with foil covers and shit; make a killing. What do you think they did?
The ‘Metal’ stuff was mind numbingly bad but DC made their cash and then they
jettisoned the wack job. Since then Snyder’s been shaking in his writer’s
chair, yelping ‘Pointy Pointy coming to
get me’ every few minutes while he pops out new comic story lines.
He’s
got his pointy fingers in the amazing new DSTLRY line with his upcoming ‘White Boat’ horror series. It remains to
be seen if he’s exorcised the Nine Inch Nails from his psyche. Maybe DSTLRY did
an intervention on him and shook him back to a balanced bad ass comic book
writer. It's not that Scott's not one of the most talented writers in the industry. It just seems he can't help himself at the conclusion of each of his books to crumble into the Spiky Evil imagery that seems to torment him. Whatever the case may be, I’ll always drop coin for a Scott Snyder
book. It may be bat shit crazy, but it’ll be wonderfully entertaining – at
least until the Pointy Pointy shows up.
Rating: 6.1
Verdict: Don't ever point at Scott Snyder